The SHIFT: Less Screen Time, More Teaching Using Instructional Technology When It Matters

Less screen time, more teaching: when instructional technology truly improves learning and when it gets in the way of teacher-led instruction.

✓
Odette Falone
Reviewed by Odette Falone, Director of Instructional Strategy and Delivery
Topic
Improved Instruction
3 sections
8 min read
✦
✦
✦
On this page

✦ Key takeaways

  • Use technology when it substantially improves what students learn or how they learn it, not by default.
  • Long stretches of solo screen time on software pathways are not the same as effective instruction. An actively engaged teacher is.
  • Technology adds the most value at the Modification and Redefinition levels of SAMR. Cut uses that only substitute for or slightly augment traditional methods.
  • A strong lesson model is Teacher, then Technology, then Teacher: the teacher sets purpose, technology gives focused practice or feedback, and the teacher checks understanding.
Inspired Blog title graphic for The SHIFT, showing the SHIFT Model framework on a chalkboard

                                       "Computers are useless. They can only give you answers."

                                                                                                                 ~Pablo Picasso

             Does your use of instructional technology substantially improve what students learn or

                                                                        how they learn it?

In the broadest sense, instructional technology has tremendous potential to improve student learning. But technology can also interfere with learning when increased screen time replaces effective teacher-led instruction, discussion, collaboration, and guided practice. The social facets of learning are irreplaceable. So the question becomes not whether schools should use technology, but rather when technology should be used because it substantially improves teaching and learning.

It is time to reexamine our instructional technology practices in the ever-changing educational landscape. The SAMR Model of instructional technology integration has been a prevailing framework over the past decade.

The SAMR Model: a framework for integrating technology into instruction (substitution, augmentation, modification, redefinition)

At first, instructional technology use was encouraged at the Substitution and Augmentation levels as a way to gain a foothold in the classroom, while Modification and Redefinition were considered the ultimate goals. Unfortunately, the model evolved into a ladder – or incremental continuum – for instructional technology integration. In reality, the levels are mutually exclusive and independent of one another. 

Screen Time and the Unintended Outcome of Instructional Technology

Schools have invested heavily in instructional technology: one-to-one devices, digital curricula, digital textbooks, learning platforms, and more. Students increasingly experience learning as:

  • Log in.
  • Put on headphones.
  • Complete the assigned module.
  • Submit.
  • Move to the next activity.

Technology gradually shifted from being an instructional support to becoming a primary means of delivering instruction. Efficiency and individualization are valuable, but independent software work is not synonymous with effective instruction.

Classroom Technology and Screen Time Practices to Re-examine

  • Assigning students extended periods during the school day to work individually on a technology-driven learning pathway without a teacher actively leading the activity. Effective instruction requires an actively engaged teacher.
  • Having students work individually on devices when the task is better suited for collaborative student interaction. Instead, structure the activity around groups of students sharing a single device.
  • Purchasing online curricula designed for students to progress incrementally and independently through material each day. Instead, use such materials to support classroom presentations, teacher-led instruction, and guided learning.
  • Allowing students to work on devices while the teacher sits at a desk disengaged from the learning process.

A Course Correction: The SHIFT to a More Strategic Approach to Instructional Technology.

It’s time for a SHIFT in instructional technology use. Technology no longer needs to gain a foothold in the classroom. Instructional technology is already abundantly available and deeply embedded in today’s classrooms. It is now time to harness its power more effectively and strategically.

We need to “bring teaching back” through strategic, high-impact classroom instruction supported by focused, purposeful use of instructional technology. Eliminate or significantly reduce the use of technology when it merely substitutes for or slightly augments more traditional instructional methods. Reclaim teacher-led instruction at each of these levels.

The SHIFT Model: a framework for strategic, high-impact instruction with focused technology, showing how often to use each SAMR level

Effective Teacher-Led Classroom Instruction

We would be hard-pressed to find a technology solution that can outperform a highly effective classroom teacher implementing any of the following research-based best practices:

  • Positive teacher-student relationships.
  • Explicit/direct instruction.
  • Modeling and think-alouds.
  • Formative assessment and checks for understanding.
  • Immediate feedback.
  • Purposeful questioning.
  • Classroom discussion and academic discourse.
  • Scaffolding.
  • Flexible small-group instruction.
  • Differentiation based on observed student needs.

(Hattie et al., 2023) 

Using Instructional Technology in a Supporting Role

The power of instructional technology lies primarily in the “M” and “R” levels of the SAMR Model. At these levels, technology is strategically focused on areas where it can support the classroom teacher in enhancing student learning.  From the best-practice strategies listed above, technology can strengthen instruction when applied in a focused, limited, and purposeful manner. For example:

  1. Small-group instruction using a single device on which students work collaboratively.
  2. Immediate feedback during formative assessment, such as a five-minute check for understanding.
  3. Differentiated, individualized interventions of limited duration with expert teacher oversight.

Guiding Question for Lesson Design

Every teacher and school leader should be asking the same question: Does technology substantially improve what students will learn or how they will learn it?

If NO:
Consider teacher-directed instruction, discussion, paper-and-pencil tasks, manipulatives, collaboration, guided practice, or other non-device approaches.

If YES:
Use the technology intentionally to achieve the intended improvement.

The future classroom does not need to choose between teachers and technology. A more purposeful, blended model is Teacher → Technology → Teacher

Lesson flow: the teacher introduces and models, technology provides targeted support, then the teacher checks understanding and differentiates
  1. The teacher introduces, models, questions, scaffolds, and establishes purpose.
  2. Strategic, focused technology use provides targeted practice, information, feedback, simulation, creation, or access.
  3. The teacher then checks for understanding, facilitates discussion, addresses misconceptions, differentiates, and moves learning forward.

‍

Back to the Essential Question

Does your use of instructional technology substantially improve what students learn or how they learn it?

The goal is not to eliminate technology from classrooms. The goal is to become more intentional about when technology adds instructional value—and when direct teacher instruction, discussion, collaboration, and guided practice are more effective.

Less low-value technology. More high-value teaching. Position technology as an instructional tool in the teacher’s hands, not as an instructional destination for students.

Less screen time. More teaching.

Use technology less often, but use it more powerfully. Replace passive or routine screen time with active instruction, meaningful interaction, and purposeful learning.

“Technology is just a tool. In terms of getting the kids working together and motivating them, the teacher is the most important.”

                                                                                                                                                    ~Bill Gates

‍

Want to explore how the SHIFT can help teachers reduce low-value screen time while using technology more strategically?

                                                                  Join our free Inspired Webinar. 

Inspired Instruction webinar: The SHIFT to Less Screen Time with Michele Regan, Senior Client Director, October 22 at 1:00 PM EST

‍

References

Fifield, W. (1964). Pablo Picasso: A composite interview. The Paris Review, 32, 37–62. 

Gates, B. (1997, October 12). Interview in The Independent on Sunday. 

Hattie, J., Fisher, D., & Frey, N. (2023). Visible learning: The sequel. Corwin.

Puentedura, R. R. (2006). Transformation, technology, and education. Handbook of research on educational communication and technology, 255-297. 

‍

FREE PDF
SHIFT Model - Strategic Instruction Focused EdTech
Free download for this topic
SHIFT Model - Strategic Instruction Focused EdTech

Prioritize teacher-led instruction while using technology strategically to deepen learning and increase instructional impact.

Download free
Rob McGee, Ph.D
Rob McGee, Ph.D
He specializes in Leadership, Administration, and Math

Rob McGee is an Instructional Strategist who works with teachers and school leaders to improve professional practices in a multitude of areas. With a differentiated approach to incremental improvement, he works collegially with the school and staff to help find the best path forward given the unique needs of each environment.

Rob has over 36 years of experience in education including math teacher, instructional coach, high school principal, director of curriculum and instruction and superintendent of schools. He earned his Ph.D. from Drexel University in Educational Leadership.

As a life-long educator, Rob believes those who work daily with our children are the true unsung heroes of our communities. His favorite quote is, “A society grows great when members plant trees in whose shade they shall never sit.” Educators plant trees every day.

In his free time, Rob enjoys flower gardening, watching his Phillies and Eagles, reading and road trips with his wife and beagle.

Meet the author →
Odette Falone
Reviewed for accuracy by Odette Falone, Director of Instructional Strategy and Delivery.

Turn this post into PD for your team

We have led 1,000+ workshops for K-12 educators and families.

Schedule a Call

Keep reading

×
Free PDF
Get your free download
Tell us a little about you and the file opens right away.
White check mark inside a green circle symbolizing approval or success.
Click the button below to download the file.
Open your PDF
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Receive the latest resources and best practices delivered to your inbox.

Join 5,000+ subscribers.
doodle